Thursday, November 11, 2010

The other side of the Killing Fields




I’ve chosen to publish this from the raw format I wrote in that day: Here it is. Today I went to the S21 Torture Concentration Camp and the Killing Fields in Cambodia.

I’ve had one of those days whereby people have warned me, tales have told me and the world all knows, but somehow, when you are there, personally there, no-one can prepare you for what you will experience in that moment.

Our day started at the Tabitha Foundation, talking though the whole house building process. It was comical to start of with, telling us stories of how Tabitha are now responsible building the house foundations because teams before us we’re not so crash hot at the laying the foundation of the houses as a result, there were some casualties. So we were just here to hammer the floors and walls. Hammer, hammer, hammer - warned to watch for our thumbs, because it was bloody painful to get hit, time after time. We all laughed and joked and then there was silence for we were about to be told the truth of why we were here.

Nari, our host, told us of her story. She apologised for her broken English and she asked for us to bare with her and hoped that we would understand what she was trying to convey. There was no need to do so, we would all know in our heads, hearts and minds that what she was sharing was an honest reality of years of anguish, not quite reconciled.  By the time we had heard what she had to say, even those that had been there before, would be hit by a wave of sorrow and sadness, empathic to her cause.

The Khmer Rouge had told her entire family, and in fact the entire town that they needed to flee from Phnom Pehn for three days to be protected from a threat of war. They gathered with them a small amount of clothes and money to see them through a short stint away from home. Three days turned into three and half years, she told us.  She was stoic until this point. Then the glisten of tears formed in her eyes.

She told us she was separated from her family and forced to live with girls her own age. She was just 14, so young, so little, so innocent.  I knew girls her age, and what it was like myself.  No-one was allowed to show or express any kind of emotion or fear with the each other. They were forbidden to feel she explained. Their clothes were removed and they were forced to wear black.  Numb, isolated in confined communities frozen by horror of what may happen to them if they did not obey.

Her chin started to quiver and her eyes well. To me, it sounded surreal.  I couldn’t relate to what she was saying at first; incredible the strength and power of denial; I simply didn’t want to. Watching her and listening to even the sound of her voice, so raw and emotional, even some 32 years on, was too greater force for even my defiance to last.  My nose went first, then my eyes over flowed, a tear dropped to my chin; quivering, my chest felt rock hard as my mouth and lips swallowed my deepest breath. I was now completely connected to what she was saying.

She told us that she and the other teenagers worked form 4am and worked until 9pm, all day in the fields with hardly any water or food to eat. And that they all feared the night the most. She said again, they hated the night. She paused. And my chest sunk. Tears were streaming down my face. I knew what she was going to tell us was not going to be the entire truth. I could see sorrow and shame on her face. She didn’t need to tell us all, but a story was given about people never returning after the night visits, and that was enough.

She paused and cried. I could tell on her face she wasn’t telling us the whole truth. There was so much more to her story. Our camera’s stopped at this point and the room was still. Completely still, we were with her, even those that had been before.

I didn’t want to go to the Killing Fields. I had hoped to visit an orphanage instead; I wanted to deny this experience. However, I chose to follow the group and get on the bus to go there. The group satisfied my need for distraction with great chatter and talk.

Arriving at S-21, Dougie,our leader, explained that lunch was at the restaurant opposite at 12pm, at this point it was 10am. He told us, if anyone needed to retreat before lunch, they could. In my mind I heard if you don’t like this - get out.

I had said to a few of the group that I wouldn’t cope too well with this, and each agreed, there was no protecting any of us from what we were about to feel walking into that place.

Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum, the former Security Office 21 in “Democratic Kampuchea” was created by the orders of Pol Pot. IN April 17, 1975. Office 21 was called S-21 and designed for the detention and interrogation, inhuman torture, and killing after confession from the detainees were received and documented. From the moment I walked in, I felt it, a tight ball of hard torn hot energy in my chest. I felt sick. Immediately. I’d taken literally ten steps inside the compound.

We stopped at the signpost that framed the circumstances. Pol Pot had tricked the people into highlighting that were doctors, lawyers, teachers or what he had called Intellects and they were all captured and brought to S-21 to be tortured to understand remove them from society. These people were tortured for names of others, or merely because they had been educated or considered a threat to the communist regime.

Nari had cried earlier saying that what these people had gone through was nothing like the days of Hitler, because he didn’t kill his own people. Pol Pot had no regard for his own countrymen. It was all about killing off the strong to have control.

I walked around the grounds solo. I wept constantly. I walked past trees where prisoners, innocent teachers and doctors had been tied and tortured to an inch of their life. The marking on the tress were as if some one had taken an axe to the raw wood, but we knew, I knew, that there had been flesh before the wood was hacked out.

I broke away from the others and took myself to the rooms where there photographs of all the prisoners. I was hung of energy, overwhelmed by the sense that I was actually in the room filled with photos of every single victim killed. Hundreds of them, black and white faces in front me was paralysing my body, yet my face felt tears. There was so much sadness and sorrow in this room, and it wasn’t just mine, it was with every single person alive, walking through that room, not wanting to make eye contact with a living being, lifiting their glaze on to the eyes of the photos.

I wanted to walk out, it was overwhelming, but then I noticed a look on one mans face in a photo. It stoped me. I caught my tears in my throat and walked towards him to look closer. I was intrigued, there was a look of something more than a victim, it was almost a smerk. There was anger in his eyes and defiance in his expression. I sighed, a real “fuck you” expression, actually.

I’m fascinated by micro expressions and what our face really tells what we are feeling. I was compelled to look and wanted to see more “life” in these photos. In fact, most of the men had these looks; it was a look of “you might torture me, you might do inhuman acts to me, but you wont break me”. There was real courage in some of these men’s expressions. My breath drew so much deeper and stronger by seeing this.

Then I looked at the women. You could tell the ones that had been raped and molested. There was a look of shame in most of their eyes, some mixed with anger, so mixed with sadness. There certainly were no real blank expressions, masks maybe, but if you really looked, you could see. Essentially, there was a story on each of their faces, I didn’t need to read about the electrocutions, hangings, tree beatings, and rape or fingernail removals to know they’d been through a living nightmare.

We lunched and moved on to the Killing Fields. Again, I didn’t want to connect with what my head knew would be a horrible experience. Six of us hired a guide. Sitting under a tree beside the shrine of the 9000 skulls that were recovered, we were told that Khmer Rouge were instructed not to waste bullets, rather, these men, woman and children where killed using axes, pickets, rakes and and tree trunks before being kicked into a dug out grave.

The first grave we saw had 486 bodies in it. It was the size of a billiard table. I started to convulse with nausea. I had just read in a book that it was teenagers and boys that were the killers, these kids were brain washed, or forced to do these murders and the vision of these hinaus acts were making me sick to the stomach.

We walked further round the pathways of the fields. There were floods in the near by damn, so to our horror, the bodies were starting to come out of the ground. Clothes, bones and teeth were randomly poking out of the dirt track. They had only recovered 9800 of the 20,000 bodies that were believed to be slaughtered there.

We then came to path where the burial site laid for woman and children. Beside which, stood a mamouth tree, a oak with a wide glorious trunk. I had read about this in the bus on the way there, the young vigilantes would smash the babies heads against the tree trunk and then throw them in the pit. Pol Pot believed that he had to kill the root of the tree, and that meant, to kill the family of the intellects so that no survivors could seek revenge. At the moment, I really could visualise it. Oh. Smash. I didn't want to feel at this point. I didn't want an imagination. Floods of salty water dripped into my mouth again, streaming, my shoulder sunk and my body wanting to turn but so heavy. I wanted to see anything but this.

I turned and there was the “Hanging tree”. This tree was where men that were noisy as there were being killed were hung to silence them.  This is not what I wanted to turn to see. My mind rife with imagination- I saw spindly bodies hanging from these magnificent out reaching branches, all blowing in the wind, hanging there. Silent.

At that point, I utterly lost it. I didn’t want to connect with this any more, I wanted denial so much and  wanted to be back in that place before I got on the bus, happy with no experience. I was so scared to run because I was afraid that I would tread on burial grounds and for a moment I felt completely trapped.

I am not religious but I said a pray and I asked for forgiveness - so I ran. Back trough the path beyond the hanging tree, out to a wooden seat next to the soda stand. All I could do was curl my body in a babe shape and hug my knees. I was a mess with wetness from tears and streaming snot - I had no tissues left, and all I had to use was my shorts. I felt sick.

These innocent people were killed because they were educated. As I felt sick for the dead, I also felt such remorse for those who had been force to kill, because even if they were not formally brought to justice, they had their own life long penalty of mental anguish and nightmares of what they had done to their fellow countrymen. That in itself would be utter torture to a man corrupted by a force stronger than he.

The whole way back in the bus everyone was silent. No chatter, just very pensive, introspective people, all very shaken, moved by what they’d just seen.

The other side of what I experienced is this – apart from the bloodshed and physical torture, what kept creeping into my mind was this - that in our lives, in our work places and families, this kind of behaviour is prevalent in our every day worlds and we just come to accept it.

Meaning, that we are conditioned to either conform to a culture, a way of life because we are told, “that is just the way it is”. The ever prominent “just because theory” that I talk about often. It is what is because that’s just the way we do things, and common folk fear to have the presence, or the confidence to question, because of the trepidation of exile.

We’re conditioned to it. Society wants us all to be the same. Insurance policies want us all to be married, banks wants us to have a mortgage, families want us married no matter what, companies want us all to fit in to the “culture” and do what we’re told. The government wants us to all conform to regulation for order. And so on….

In so many ways we have people controlling us every day of our lives. It’s so rare that people stand up and say, “you know what, how does a big fat no sound, I’m going to do this……!" And you know what, when one says it, I can assure you, there are a majority of people in that group that all think it, but wont come forward. Condition is what we know.  What we know is what we are comfortable with. No matter how awful it might seem. It’s too scary to change. Do you know what I’m saying??

 Is the responsibility of being a member of society really democratic?

I got incredibly upset that no greater force such as the United Nations did anything to stop this atrocity. But then I came to realise that forces are greater than what any of us realise. Politics, socialisms, communism, culture, peer pressure, fear, desire, belief, religion. Family. Love.


What about the individual? Nari was the only survivor of her family. She was alone, striving to create a world that was better for her people. She is a survivor.

I always want to say something inspirational at the end of all of my blogs, but for now I'm focused and really care about telling the story.

But here goes; bless the survivors of the world - no matter what you have had to endure, somehow you're not alone.


TBS xx

12 comments:

Doug said...

The horror of one man has created love amongst mankind. May we always see for the blind, hear for the deaf and speak up for the silenced.

Anonymous said...

Amazing Fleur, what an incredible experience. Really lost for words, but proud to have you as my daughter. Mum xxx

Anonymous said...

Loved your blog on the Killing Fields. Felt like I was right there with you. Well, I always am. Well done TBS

Anonymous said...

I read your blog with tears streaming down my face. I could not speak or explain how I was feeling to my colleagues. I think you captured exactly how I felt and how I am feeling a week on.

Anonymous said...

OH Great blog Flower! I could feel and see exactly through your descriptions! I am still confounded that such atrocity occurred in our lifetime and ashamed that until I read about it 2 years ago I had no idea of the extent of the Khmer Roug...

Anonymous said...

wonderful blog TBS - yes sadly we all live in a 'nanny state' what ever our political or religious persuasion.

Anonymous said...

Amazing post, and I was thinking the same thoughts about how we comply with the 'just because' mentality. Auschwitz, the Killing Fields, the Gulags, Rwanda etc...

Anonymous said...

Very touching Fleur! Lovely, rich writing! You have a real talent there. I did read "The other side of the killing fields". I must confess somewhat reluctantly once I had read the house building blog...I knew it would be
rich. It was. I cant comprehend what you went through there. Just reading it was a scary and teary experience. Of all the species on this planet, only humans does things like this to fellow humans. Thank you for sharing.

Bill said...

a flood of memories rush back to me...

Chelise said...

Nice one, Grande. It was interesting for me to read an emotional account after having being there myself (before we met) and not feel too much at all. Those 7 rooms with the pictures in them really messed me up. Those photos above the beds are photos taken as the room was found when the Vietnamese liberated the camp. I had an actual physical reaction each time I entered one of those rooms. I felt very dizzy and off balance. I thought I was crazy, but it happened each time. I have since had that same experience when visiting Dachau in Germany.

Anonymous said...

I read both Cambodia blogs today and thought it some of the best writing you've done. On the topic you chose, I've been to Toul Sleng I though it remarkable. I was very interested that you might be one of the first people I know to question philanthropy as it stands. Even though you moved on in the article, I felt you raised the question by noting how people change in the their response.
I met clare at a world vision lecture when tim Costello talked about empowering the people you were helping. But they still seem to free a lot of the old ways, which I feel leads to disillusionment in the long run. Anyway, I don't know what job you're looking at for the future. But there is a real question and I think another tragedy going on in Cambodia and that is the amount of current aid given to Cambodia and where it goes. Also the fact that there are some of the richest people in the world there now, Hun Sen and his boys, and yet western countries still give. Lot's is going to Hun Sen and his party and the people are not always recipients. It's almost like an accepted tragedy because people aren't being beaten against trees. Which I think is a terrible blight on humanity and the UN, and Australia. We offer a lot of aid but little follow up on how and to whom it is received.
If you were interested in an article of substance to focus this story around. Look to the lake in Phenom Phen. I remember it when no one cared about the area and no the people are being "flooded out". I could give you a lot of info and where to search if you were to follow up. But remember if you did write such an article, it would he the last time you could visit Cambodia. But I think you could do a great job. There are grant for this kind of writing though you kgut have to apply for a course. Ps. You write much better than I and I couldn't manage it. I've been want to get it down for ten years.

Anonymous said...

these people weren't killed because they were educated.

they were killed because they were in positions of power and had the ways and means for decades to change the awful cambodia the peasants faced. yet they did nothing. there would have been two cambodias forever, the peasants and the rest. Look at Haiti if you need an example. People eat dirt to survive and the many in the country that could make a change have done nothing to do so.

evil prospers when good men stand idly by and do nothing to stop it. IMO Pot wanted to send a message to the rest of the world that if you have the means to make change and do nothing don't be surprised if one day you get called to task for it.

unfortunately, nothing was learned by the rest of the world by Pot's actions. Even when the rest of the world saw many being executed for the sins of their fathers they still did nothing to look around their own country and ask what they could do to make the life of the poor and oppressed better. Even now the status quo is for the better off to constantly deprive and take advantage of the poor and ignorant.

It took me years to figure this out and I'm not done learning. I'm also not condoning what Pot did. But I wonder why so many in the west who have contributed to such misery in their own countries are allowed to walk away from the misery and destitution they cause with a big bag of money?